On the ancient themeslearning to ask from the one who prays
In a Certain Place
Father, they watched your Son pray.
Luke kept seeing it. When all the people had been baptized, "Jesus also had been baptized, and was praying. The sky was opened" (). When the crowds grew, "he withdrew himself into the desert, and prayed" (). Before he chose the twelve, "he went out to the mountain to pray, and he continued all night in prayer to God" (). "As he was praying alone, the disciples were with him" (). On another mountain, "As he was praying, the appearance of his face was altered" ().
They had seen him like this before. And one day they waited.
"When he finished praying in a certain place, one of his disciples said to him, 'Lord, teach us to pray, just as John also taught his disciples'" ().
Luke does not say where the place was. He does not say how long they stood there, or what they could hear, or which of them spoke. Only that they let him finish. Whatever was passing between you and your Son in that place, they did not break into it. They waited at the edge of it, and when it was over they asked to be let in.
We have stood at that edge. Some of us learned to pray by watching someone else do it: a grandmother at a kitchen table, a friend who closed her eyes in a hospital corridor, a stranger in the back pew whose lips were moving. Some of us have never watched anyone pray, and have come the way they came, wanting the words. And some of us have prayed so long for one person that we no longer know whether we are praying or only standing at a door.
So we bring you the question underneath theirs. It is not how. It is older than that.
When we pray, are we beginning, or are we joining in?
And if we are joining in, then another, which we hardly dare to ask: who are we, that your Son should pray for us?
Lord, teach us to pray. We are standing where they stood. We will wait until he finishes.
He gave them words.
He said to them, "When you pray, say," and gave them this:
Our Father in heaven, may your name be kept holy. May your Kingdom come. May your will be done on earth, as it is in heaven. Give us day by day our daily bread. Forgive us our sins, for we ourselves also forgive everyone who is indebted to us. Bring us not into temptation, but deliver us from the evil one. ()
The word it calls the Father by is his own. In Luke, every prayer of his whose words we are given calls on that name. When the seventy came back with joy, he prayed, "I thank you, O Father, Lord of heaven and earth" (). On the Mount of Olives it will be "Father, if you are willing" (). On the cross, "Father, forgive them" (), and at the very end, "Father, into your hands I commit my spirit!" (). He did not teach them a word he did not use. He put his own word for the Father in their mouths.
And everything he asks in it, he asks in the plural: give us, forgive us, bring us not. No one in it prays alone. No one in it asks only for themselves.
"Give us day by day our daily bread." Bread for one day, asked for again the next, the way the manna came in the wilderness, "a day's portion every day" ().
Then, still answering them, he told them a story about bread.
"He said to them, 'Which of you, if you go to a friend at midnight, and tell him, "Friend, lend me three loaves of bread, for a friend of mine has come to me from a journey, and I have nothing to set before him"'" ().
Three friends in one sentence. One has been on the road and arrives at an hour when no one arrives. One has a house and a door and nothing to put on the table. One is in bed with his children around him. The story is about the one in the middle.
I have nothing to set before him.
Most of us have had that night. Someone we love comes to our door at the wrong hour, and we have nothing. The scan has come back. A friend sits on the edge of our couch and says the thing she has never said to anyone, and we have no bread for it. We are not the one who is hungry. We are the one standing in the doorway, unable to feed them.
So the man goes out in the dark, to somebody else's door. He is not asking for himself.
Among the papers found ready for the press when John Bunyan died was a small book on one verse of Hebrews, the verse about the Son who lives to pray for us. Near its beginning Bunyan stops to say what intercession is. "Intercession is prayer; but all prayer is not intercession. Intercession, then, is that prayer that is made by a third person about the concerns that are between two." It can be made against someone, he says, or it can be made "to make them friends."
The man at the door at midnight is a third person. He stands between a friend who is hungry and a friend who is asleep, and he calls through the shut door.
And the answer from inside is no. "Don't bother me. The door is now shut, and my children are with me in bed. I can't get up and give it to you" ().
Gregory the Great was asked once about doors like that. In his Dialogues his deacon asks him whether holy men can "obtain at God's hands whatsoever they desire." Gregory does not say yes. He reminds him of St. Paul, "who yet three times desired our Lord to be delivered from the prick of the flesh, and obtained not his petition," and then tells of "one thing which the venerable father Benedict would have done, and yet he could not."
Benedict's sister, "called Scholastica, dedicated from her infancy to our Lord, used once a year to come and visit her brother." He would go out to meet her at a place that belonged to the abbey, not far from its gate. One year, when she came as she always did, "they spent the whole day in the praises of God and spiritual talk: and when it was almost night they supped together." They were still at the table, still talking, when "darkness came on," and she asked him to stay the night, "that they might spend it in discoursing of the joys of heaven."
He would not. He said "he might not by any means tarry all night out of his Abbey."
The door is now shut.
"At that time, the sky was so clear that no cloud was to be seen." She put her hands together and laid them on the table, and laid her head on them. Gregory tells it as a single movement: "joining her hands together, laid them upon the table: and so, bowing down her head upon them, she made her prayers to almighty God: and lifting her head from the table, there fell suddenly such a tempest of lightning and thundering, and such abundance of rain, that neither venerable Benedict, nor his monks that were with him, could put their head out of door." She had wept, he says, and "poured forth such a flood of tears upon the table, that she drew the clear air to a watery sky."
Benedict "began to be heavy and to complain of his sister, saying: 'God forgive you, what have you done?'"
And she said: "I desired you to stay, and you would not hear me, I have desired our good Lord, and he hath vouchsafed to grant my petition: wherefore if you can now depart, in God's name return to your monastery, and leave me here alone."
He could not go. "And so by that means they watched all night, and with spiritual and heavenly talk did mutually comfort one another." Gregory gives the reason in a few words: "she did more which loved more."
She had asked for one more night. In the morning she went back to her nunnery and he to his abbey, and three days after, Benedict, "standing in his cell, and lifting up his eyes to heaven, beheld the soul of his sister (which was departed from her body), in the likeness of a dove to ascend into heaven." He sent his monks to bring her body to the abbey, and had her laid "in that grave which he had provided for himself."
He watched her go. Gregory says he was "rejoicing much to see her great glory," and gave thanks "with hymns and lauds." She had asked for one more night "discoursing of the joys of heaven," and three days after they parted her brother saw her go where they had talked of all night. "As their souls were always one in God whiles they lived, so their bodies continued together after their death."
The brother would not open the door. The Lord did. And even in Luke's story, the friend in bed gets up in the end. "I tell you, although he will not rise and give it to him because he is his friend, yet because of his persistence, he will get up and give him as many as he needs" ().
Persistence. The older English Bibles had another word for it there: importunity.
The same word turns up in the English of Augustine's Confessions, about his mother, Monica. He wrote the Confessions to you, Father, and so he tells you what you already knew: that for "almost nine years" he lived "in the mire of that deep pit, and the darkness of falsehood, often assaying to rise, but dashed down the more grievously." "All which time that chaste, godly, and sober widow (such as Thou lovest), now more cheered with hope, yet no whit relaxing in her weeping and mourning, ceased not at all hours of her devotions to bewail my case unto Thee. And her prayers entered into Thy presence; and yet Thou sufferedst me to be yet involved and reinvolved in that darkness."
Almost nine years of knocking, and the door stayed shut.
In those years she went to another door. There was a bishop, "brought up in Thy Church, and well studied in Thy books," and she begged him to talk to her son, to "refute my errors, unteach me ill things, and teach me good things." He refused. Her son was not ready to be taught, he told her: "let him alone a while … only pray God for him." She would not take it. She "urged him more, with entreaties and many tears," and at last he, "a little displeased at her importunity, saith, 'Go thy ways and God bless thee, for it is not possible that the son of these tears should perish.'"
"Which answer she took (as she often mentioned in her conversations with me) as if it had sounded from heaven."
"I tell you, keep asking, and it will be given you. Keep seeking, and you will find. Keep knocking, and it will be opened to you. For everyone who asks receives. He who seeks finds. To him who knocks it will be opened" ().
Bunyan wrote those words over the gate where the way begins. In The Pilgrim's Progress, when Christian comes to it, "over the gate there was written, 'Knock, and it shall be opened unto you.'" And in the second part, after Christian is gone, his wife Christiana comes to the same gate with her boys, and her friend Mercy with her.
They agreed that Christiana, being the eldest, should knock and speak for them all. She knocked, "and knocked again." A great dog barked at them from somewhere, and they were afraid to knock any more and afraid to go back, until "at last they thought of knocking again, and knocked more vehemently than they did at the first."
The Keeper of the gate asked who was there, and opened, and Christiana told him: the wife of Christian, with her sons, come on the same errand. "Then He took her by the hand, and let her in."
"Now all this while poor Mercy did stand without, trembling and crying, for fear that she was rejected. But when Christiana had gotten admittance for herself and her boys, then she began to make intercession for Mercy."
"My Lord, I have a companion of mine that stands yet without, that is come hither upon the same account as myself; one that is much dejected in her mind, for that she comes, as she thinks, without sending for; whereas I was sent to by my husband's King to come."
Mercy could not wait for the end of it. "Each minute was as long to her as an hour," and she "prevented Christiana from a fuller interceding for her, by knocking at the gate herself. And she knocked then so loud, that she made Christiana to start." The Keeper asked again who was there.
"And said Christiana, It is my friend."
A friend of mine has come to me from a journey.
When he opened the gate, Mercy "was fallen down without, in a swoon, for she fainted, and was afraid that no gate would be opened to her." He took her by the hand. "Damsel, I bid thee arise." And she told him what she was afraid of. "I am come for that unto which I was never invited, as my friend Christiana was. Hers was from the King, and mine was but from her. Wherefore I fear I presume."
Mine was but from her. Most of us came like that. Not by a summons from the King, but because someone we loved was going, and asked us to come, and spoke for us at the gate while we stood outside with no words of our own.
"Then He took her again by the hand, and led her gently in, and said, I pray for all them that believe on Me, by what means soever they come unto Me." Bunyan has the Keeper echo the prayer the Son prayed on his last night, "for those also who will believe in me through their word" (), and say it at the gate, to the one who was never invited.
Later, when they are alone in a summer parlour, Christiana tells her what the knocking sounded like from inside: "I thought I never heard such knocking in all my life; I thought you would have come in by violent hands, or have taken the kingdom by storm." And Mercy asks what she most wants to know. "But, pray, what said my Lord to my rudeness? Was He not angry with me?" "When He heard your lumbering noise, He gave a wonderful innocent smile; I believe what you did pleased Him well enough, for He showed no sign to the contrary."
The friend in Luke's story gets up because the asking will not stop. The Keeper smiles at the noise.
"Which of you fathers, if your son asks for bread, will give him a stone? Or if he asks for a fish, he won't give him a snake instead of a fish, will he? Or if he asks for an egg, he won't give him a scorpion, will he? If you then, being evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your heavenly Father give the Holy Spirit to those who ask him?" (). Matthew remembers the promise as "good things to those who ask him" (). Luke remembers it as the Holy Spirit.
Anyone who has fed a child knows the answer before he finishes asking. A small hand reaches up for bread, and nobody puts a stone in it. Even we, "being evil," would not do that. How much more.
Some of us cannot hear that without remembering what we asked for and did not get. We asked for bread. We asked that she would live, that he would come home, that the scan would be clear. What we were handed felt like a stone.
Monica asked for one thing, one night, on the shore at Carthage. Augustine had decided to go to Rome to teach. She "grievously bewailed my journey, and followed me as far as the sea," and held on to him, "that either she might keep me back or go with me." And he lied to her. "I feigned that I had a friend whom I could not leave, till he had a fair wind to sail." He invented a friend, to get away from the one who was praying for him. Some of us have been that son.
He talked her into spending that night "in a place hard by our ship, where was an Oratory in memory of the blessed Cyprian." "That night I privily departed, but she was not behind in weeping and prayer. And what, O Lord, was she with so many tears asking of Thee, but that Thou wouldest not suffer me to sail?"
"The wind blew and swelled our sails, and withdrew the shore from our sight; and she on the morrow was there, frantic with sorrow, and with complaints and groans filled Thine ears, Who didst then disregard them."
Stay with her there. It is morning. The ship is gone. She has spent the night weeping and praying in a chapel by the water for the one thing, and the one thing has not been given. Her son is on the sea, and he lied to her to get there. Nobody has told her how it ends.
And this is what she did. "And yet, after accusing my treachery and hardheartedness, she betook herself again to intercede to Thee for me, went to her wonted place, and I to Rome."
Gregory had begun with Paul: "Concerning this thing, I begged the Lord three times that it might depart from me. He has said to me, 'My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness'" (). Three times he asked. The thorn stayed. A word was given instead of the thing.
And the one who taught them to ask asked, on his last night, and the thing was not given.
He went out, Luke says, "as his custom was, to the Mount of Olives" (), and "When he was at the place, he said to them, 'Pray that you don't enter into temptation'" (). The place. Luke would not say what passed between the Father and the Son in the certain place. In this one he lets us hear it. "He was withdrawn from them about a stone's throw, and he knelt down and prayed, saying, 'Father, if you are willing, remove this cup from me. Nevertheless, not my will, but yours, be done'" (). "Being in agony he prayed more earnestly" ().
It is the prayer he taught them, prayed to the bottom. Father. Your will be done. Bring us not into temptation. And on the cross, forgiveness for the ones who were doing it: "Father, forgive them, for they don't know what they are doing" ().
The ones who had once waited for him to finish could not wait this time. He came back and "found them sleeping because of grief, and said to them, 'Why do you sleep? Rise and pray that you may not enter into temptation'" (). Luke gives their sleep its reason: grief. And he did not leave them in it. He woke them with the words he had given them. We know that sleep. Some of us were asleep down the hall at the end, worn out with sorrow, and woke to find it over. He knows why we slept.
The cup was not taken from him.
The letter to the Hebrews, looking back on the days of his flesh, says this of them: "having offered up prayers and petitions with strong crying and tears to him who was able to save him from death, and having been heard for his godly fear" (). Heard. He was heard, and he drank the cup.
We do not understand that, and we will not try to explain it to anyone standing on a shore in the morning. We know only that he knelt there first.
Augustine wrote about the night at Carthage afterward, when he knew what she had not known on the shore. "But Thou, in the depth of Thy counsels and hearing the main point of her desire, regardest not what she then asked, that Thou mightest make me what she ever asked." She asked that he would not sail. What she had always asked was that he would be yours. "She knew not how great joy Thou wert about to work for her out of my absence."
She never read that sentence. He wrote it after she had died. None of us is promised the Confessions of the one we prayed for.
Some of us are still on the shore.
We can stay there. No one is asking us to understand it yet, or to find the words.
The gift Luke names is the Holy Spirit, and Paul says what the Spirit does for people who have run out of words: "the Spirit also helps our weaknesses, for we don't know how to pray as we ought. But the Spirit himself makes intercession for us with groanings which can't be uttered" (). Augustine says that on the morning after, his mother filled God's ears "with complaints and groans." Paul says there are groanings the Spirit makes himself.
We have seen that gift given once already. At the river, "Jesus also had been baptized, and was praying. The sky was opened, and the Holy Spirit descended in a bodily form like a dove on him" (). He was praying when it came, and a voice came with it: "You are my beloved Son. In you I am well pleased" (). Stand there a moment, all of us, the glad and the grieving. The sky is open. What the Father gives to those who ask is what he gave his Son while he prayed.
To those who ask. And there are times when we can no longer tell whether we are asking at all.
Not on the shore, not at the gate. Only dry. We kneel, and get up, and nothing has happened, and we are no longer sure anything heard. We no longer know whether we are praying or only standing at a door.
Julian of Norwich knew that place, and she said so. She had been shown sixteen things in a sickness in May 1373, and spent the years after turning them over, and of her own praying she wrote: "But yet oftentimes our trust is not full: for we are not sure that God heareth us, as we think because of our unworthiness, and because we feel right nought, (for we are as barren and dry oftentimes after our prayers as we were afore); and this, in our feeling our folly, is cause of our weakness. For thus have I felt in myself."
For thus have I felt in myself. She does not say it only of other people.
And then, she says, "all this brought our Lord suddenly to my mind, and shewed these words, and said:"
I am Ground of thy beseeching: first it is my will that thou have it; and after, I make thee to will it; and after, I make thee to beseech it and thou beseechest it. How should it then be that thou shouldst not have thy beseeching?
First it is my will. And after, I make thee to will it. Even the wanting is his. If we are standing at the door at all, not sure we are praying, we are standing there because we were made to want to. Julian calls beseeching "a true, gracious, lasting will of the soul, oned and fastened into the will of our Lord by the sweet inward work of the Holy Ghost."
"Full glad and merry is our Lord of our prayer," she writes. And to the dry, the word she was given is plain: "Pray inwardly, though thee thinketh it savour thee not: for it is profitable, though thou feel not, though thou see nought; yea, though thou think thou canst not. For in dryness and in barrenness, in sickness and in feebleness, then is thy prayer well-pleasant to me, though thee thinketh it savour thee nought but little."
To anyone who has knocked a long time, she says: "But sometimes it cometh to our mind that we have prayed long time, and yet we think to ourselves that we have not our asking. But herefor should we not be in heaviness. For I am sure, by our Lord's signifying, that either we abide a better time, or more grace, or a better gift."
And she was shown this: "Behold and see that I have done all this before thy prayers; and now thou art, and prayest me."
Before thy prayers.
At the table on his last night, after he had given them the bread and the cup, "there arose also a contention among them, which of them was considered to be greatest" (). He answered it. And then he spoke to one of them by name. "Simon, Simon, behold, Satan asked to have all of you, that he might sift you as wheat, but I prayed for you, that your faith wouldn't fail. You, when once you have turned again, establish your brothers" ().
He says the name twice.
Luke records no asking from Simon. What Simon said was this: "Lord, I am ready to go with you both to prison and to death!" (). And by the time the rooster crowed he had said three times that he did not know him. "The Lord turned, and looked at Peter," and Peter "went out, and wept bitterly" ().
The prayer had come first. Before the boast, before the courtyard and the fire, before Simon knew he would need it: "I prayed for you." Not that he would not fall. That his faith would not fail. And the Son speaks past the fall, to the morning after it: "when once you have turned again, establish your brothers." He gives him work to do on the far side of what he has not yet done. And Luke keeps the promise in his second book: "In these days, Peter stood up in the middle of the disciples" ().
That was not the last time he prayed for them. "But he, because he lives forever, has his priesthood unchangeable. Therefore he is also able to save to the uttermost those who draw near to God through him, seeing that he lives forever to make intercession for them" (). The one who prayed "to him who was able to save him from death" now "lives forever." He was heard.
Bunyan tells his reader to look up from the cross for a moment and "follow him to where he is now, and then you shall see him in his robes, in his priestly robes," "wearing the breastplate of judgment, and with all your names written upon his heart." It is the breastplate of the old priesthood: "Aaron shall bear the names of the children of Israel in the breastplate of judgment on his heart, when he goes in to the holy place, for a memorial before Yahweh continually" (). Names, carried in on a heart, continually. The names of the ones who go out at midnight for someone else's bread are carried in too.
Simon, Simon.
They waited until he finished praying, and then they asked to be taught. He gave them his own word, a story about a friend at midnight, and a promise about a Father. Then he went on praying: for Simon at the table, for himself on the Mount of Olives, for the ones who crucified him. "He lives forever to make intercession for them."
They waited for him to finish. He has not finished.
Father.
It is the word he gave us, and we say it.
We do not know how to pray. We have watched others do it. We have waited at the edge of it. We have asked. Teach us, as he taught them, in a certain place we cannot name.
We bring you the ones we have nothing to set before. You know their names; some of us cannot say them without crying, and some of us have said them so many times they have worn smooth. We have no bread for them. We are knocking at your door at midnight on their behalf, and we are not ashamed to keep knocking.
And some of us have stopped knocking. We gave it up because we were ashamed of the life we would have to bring with us, or because we fell asleep a stone's throw from the place and could not face waking. Wake us with the words he gave us. Let us begin again where we left off, however far back that was.
Some of us have knocked for years, and some are on the shore in the morning, and the sails are gone, and we do not know how it ends. We will not pretend to understand what you have not given. We set it down beside his cup, the one he asked you to take away and drank, and we leave it there with him.
Give us day by day our daily bread. Forgive us our sins, for we ourselves also forgive everyone who is indebted to us; and where we cannot yet, forgive us that. Bring us not into temptation, but deliver us from the evil one.
Some of us came to you the way Mercy came, not invited by the King but brought by someone who loved us and spoke for us while we stood outside. Hear them for us still. And if the one who prayed for us is gone, and the voice that spoke for us at the gate has gone quiet, let us know, in the quiet, that he has not. And let us speak at the gate for the ones who are standing outside now, trembling, sure that no door will open to them.
When we cannot pray, because there will be mornings like that, let it be enough that he is praying. When our asking is loud and clumsy and rude, let him smile at it. When we are as dry after our prayers as we were before, remind us who made us want to pray, and let your Spirit say in us what we cannot.
We still cannot feel whether we are beginning or joining in. We know only that he was praying before we came, and that he has not stopped, and that somewhere in it, said twice, are our names.
Our Father.
Amen.
The silence is yours. A free account keeps whatever rises in it here, beside this reflection, and in your Notebook.
Begin herePass it on
Send this to someone walking with you. The card that travels with the link carries one of its lines.Or select any line above, and that one travels instead.
Draws on
Every voice named above comes from the Dia Logos Library — public domain, read in full. Nothing is attributed that cannot be opened.
Elsewhere in the chorus
Dia Logos — the chorus of the Church, speaking across time, in dialogue with each other, with Scripture, and with you.
The voices you met here did not stop at one page. Read them whole; walk a passage through the week; keep your own words beside theirs.