Skip to main content
Dia Logos

Questioningthe patient ground

crying out when the answer does not arrive


Where we are

A man stands up in the ashes and speaks straight to God. He has cried and heard nothing; what has come back is a look, and then a hand.

This week's word

“I cry to you, and you do not answer me. I stand up, and you gaze at me. You have turned to be cruel to me. With the might of your hand you persecute me. You lift me up to the wind, and drive me with it. You dissolve me in the storm. For I know that you will bring me to death, To the house appointed for all living.”

Reflection

Job does not hedge. He will not soften the charge or dress it in the language of submission. "I cry to you, and you do not answer me. I stand up, and you gaze at me." He stands as one stands to pray, on his feet before God, and what comes back is a look.

To be seen and not answered is a different kind of abandonment. An empty sky would leave a little room: perhaps no one heard. Job has no such room. He can feel the eyes on him, and still nothing is said.

Then the lines go further than silence, further than most of us would let a prayer go. "You have turned to be cruel to me. With the might of your hand you persecute me. You lift me up to the wind, and drive me with it. You dissolve me in the storm." The God of these lines is near enough to take hold of Job and strong enough to lift him, and to Job he is an enemy. Job is describing a hand, and the hand is heavy, and it has thrown him into the weather like chaff. He knows where the wind is driving. "For I know that you will bring me to death," he says, and the place he means is "the house appointed for all living." This is the hardest thing in the passage, and Scripture lets him say it in full.

Johann Arndt's counsel for those labouring under great temptations of spirit sets Job's cry beside David's psalms and the agony of Christ. Arndt sides with Job against the friends, "who, not understanding what was the true state of his distressed and afflicted soul, reproved him as one that had lost patience, and that charged God foolishly." He knows how dark it gets. A person can feel that no trace of faith is left, and "in the height of this conflict, the Scriptures themselves afford him no comfort." He goes to the cross, where Christ cried out that he was forsaken (), and says of Christ that "He complains that he was forsaken of God, though He was continually present with him."

Arndt also has an explanation ready: "In these scriptures we may see how wonderfully all the saints and servants of God have been purified in this furnace of affliction." He may be right about the saints. Job is not given that comfort here, and Robert Watson's commentary on Job notices how firmly the book holds it back. "Job does not know that out of trouble like his a man may rise more human, more noble," he writes, and "the author keeps this thought in the background, showing hopeless sorrow, affliction, unrelieved by any sense of spiritual gain." The book could have let Job glimpse the use of the furnace. It leaves him in the wind instead, and leaves us there with him.

Look at where he says it. For most of this chapter Job speaks about God, not to him: "He has cast me into the mire." He speaks of the rabble who spit in his face, and later of his skin and his bones and his harp. Only in these four lines does he turn and say "you": "I cry to you," "You have turned to be cruel to me," "You lift me up to the wind," "you will bring me to death." He accuses God, and he does it to God's face.

Then the "you" falls away again, and he is left with himself. "However doesn’t one stretch out a hand in his fall? Or in his calamity therefore cry for help?" A falling man throws out a hand; a body does that before it has chosen where. Then he remembers: "Didn’t I weep for him who was in trouble? Wasn’t my soul grieved for the needy?" Watson names the ache: "He is asking in vain that pity which he himself had often shown." Job had wept for the man in trouble. Now he is that man.

To stay with this passage is to resist tidying it. We will want to hurry Job on to the furnace and its purpose, or to the last chapter of his book. These four lines are given neither. What they have is the second person. Job does not turn the charge into a description of God, or the description into a theory; he says "you," where it can be heard. If this is trust, it is trust refusing to lie about what it sees. There is no answer yet: only a man in the wind, saying to God's face what God's hand feels like.

Sit with

Is there something we have stopped saying to God because it felt too honest to say?

Your own words belong here too — what you are sitting with, a prayer, a line to carry. A free account keeps them beside this devotional, and gathers each week's into your Notebook.

Begin here

Prayer

God of Job, we will not pretend with you. Some of us have cried and heard nothing back, and stood up and felt only your eyes on us. Some of us feel your hand, and it does not feel kind. We will not repeat to you the explanations that were offered to Job. Job said "you" to you, even with your hand heavy on him; let us say it too, and not talk about you behind your back. Lord Jesus, you cried this cry on the cross; stay near all who are crying it now, even when they cannot feel you near. Let us trust you enough to tell you the truth.

Carry into the week

Even the hardest cry can be spoken to God's face.

Pass it on

Send this to someone walking with you. The card that travels with the link carries one of its lines.Or select any line above, and that one travels instead.

Draws on

Every voice named above comes from the Dia Logos Library — public domain, read in full. Nothing is attributed that cannot be opened.

Written to the Church.

This week in the chorus

Elsewhere in the chorus

Dia Logos — the chorus of the Church, speaking across time, in dialogue with each other, with Scripture, and with you.

The voices you met here did not stop at one page. Read them whole; walk a passage through the week; keep your own words beside theirs.

Explore the Shelf