Skip to main content
Dia Logos

Questioningthe work that asks for us

why do the wicked prosper while the righteous suffer


Where we are

Jeremiah has just learned that men of his own town want him dead (Jeremiah 11:21), and he takes God to court. He grants that the Judge is righteous before he says anything else, and then lays out the case anyway: the treacherous thrive, the land withers, and the guilty say God will never see their end.

This week's word

“You are righteous, Yahweh, when I contend with you; yet I would like to reason the cause with you. Why does the way of the wicked prosper? Why are they all at ease who deal very treacherously? You have planted them. Yes, they have taken root. They grow. Yes, they produce fruit. You are near in their mouth, and far from their heart. But you, Yahweh, know me. You see me, and test my heart toward you. Pull them out like sheep for the slaughter, and prepare them for the day of slaughter. How long will the land mourn, and the herbs of the whole country wither? Because of the wickedness of those who dwell therein, the animals and birds are consumed; because they said, “He won’t see our latter end.””

Reflection

It is God who did the planting. "You have planted them. Yes, they have taken root. They grow. Yes, they produce fruit." Jeremiah will not let the problem belong to the world. He lays it at the gardener's feet. The scandal is not that the wicked succeed in spite of God, but that they succeed under his hand.

He knows how that sounds, and so he begins where a believer must begin: "You are righteous, Yahweh, when I contend with you; yet I would like to reason the cause with you." C. J. Ball gives the opening a lawyer's edge, "Too righteous art Thou, Iahvah, for me to contend with Thee: I will but lay arguments before Thee", and says the prophet means to "argue the case forensically". It is a lawsuit filed by a man who has already conceded that the Judge is just. That is what makes it so hard. If God were unjust, the prosperity of the treacherous would need no explaining.

The charge is exact. "You are near in their mouth, and far from their heart." Their mouths are full of his name, but the allegiance is performance. Jeremiah has reason to know: the men plotting his death are men of his own town, and they have Yahweh's name in their mouths even as they threaten him ().

And then he prays for blood. "But you, Yahweh, know me. You see me, and test my heart toward you. Pull them out like sheep for the slaughter, and prepare them for the day of slaughter." Only a chapter earlier Jeremiah called himself a gentle lamb led to the slaughter (). Now the lamb asks for a slaughter of his own. That is what treachery does to the people it wounds, and Scripture keeps the prayer, with the prophet's name on it, so that we will know we are not the first to pray it.

Answers have not been lacking. John Chrysostom was still preaching on the rich man and Lazarus on a fourth day, "though this be the fourth day, I do not leave the subject", because he knew that "nothing is so great a stumbling-block and causes so much religious doubt to many people" as the sight of sinners in wealth and the just in poverty. His answer is the very end that Jeremiah's enemies deny. They say, "He won’t see our latter end." Chrysostom says, "both will hereafter receive their desert". Until then, he hopes his hearers will be moved by the delights and sorrows of this life "only as we are by pictures painted on the wall", and he wants the parable written down, "the rich on the walls of their houses, the poor on the walls of their mind". It is a true answer, and it comes from Christ's own story.

But it is not the answer Jeremiah is given. God does not explain the planting. He asks a question back: "If you have run with the footmen, and they have wearied you, then how can you contend with horses? Though in a land of peace you are secure, yet how will you do in the pride of the Jordan?" And still inside that answer he names what is coming: "even your brothers, and the house of your father, even they have dealt treacherously with you!" Ball hears the horses in that line. To a man of Jeremiah's tenderness, he writes, "the thought of being forsaken by his own kindred might well appear as a trial worse than death." The question of the wicked prospering is rarely asked in the abstract; it is asked by someone whose brother is doing well.

Then the planter speaks of his own garden. "Many shepherds have destroyed my vineyard", he says, and of those in the land, "They have sown wheat, and have reaped thorns." He grieves in his own voice, "I have given the dearly beloved of my soul into the hand of her enemies", and the land, he says, "mourns to me". Jeremiah asked how long the land would mourn; it turns out the land has been mourning to God. And the one who planted will pull up. Of the nations that touch his heritage, and of Judah among them, he says, "I will pluck them up from off their land", and then, "It will happen, that after I have plucked them up, I will return and have compassion on them."

None of this tells Jeremiah why the way of the wicked prospers. It tells him that the race will get harder, that the planter will uproot what he planted, and that compassion waits on the far side of the uprooting. What the prophet is left holding is faith insisting that God be God. He stands with the footmen behind him and the horses ahead, and the question he began with still in his mouth.

Sit with

Which of Jeremiah's words have we prayed ourselves, and which have we been afraid to pray?

Your own words belong here too — what you are sitting with, a prayer, a line to carry. A free account keeps them beside this devotional, and gathers each week's into your Notebook.

Begin here

Prayer

You are righteous, Lord. We say it first, as Jeremiah did, because it is true, and then we say the rest, because you let him. We have watched the treacherous take root and bear fruit. We have heard your name in mouths whose hearts are far from you; sometimes the mouths were ours, and sometimes the faces belonged to our own families. You know us. You see us and test our hearts, and you have heard us ask for the slaughter of those who wronged us when we did not say it aloud. Forgive what is cruel in our asking, and do not stop us asking. You who planted, and who will pull up, we do not understand your waiting. The land still mourns, and it mourns to you. We are tired from the footmen, and we do not know how we will run with horses. Do not leave us in the pride of the Jordan without your voice. Amen.

Carry into the week

Jeremiah asked why; God asked about horses.

Pass it on

Send this to someone walking with you. The card that travels with the link carries one of its lines.Or select any line above, and that one travels instead.

Draws on

Every voice named above comes from the Dia Logos Library — public domain, read in full. Nothing is attributed that cannot be opened.

Written to the Church.

This week in the chorus

Elsewhere in the chorus

Dia Logos — the chorus of the Church, speaking across time, in dialogue with each other, with Scripture, and with you.

The voices you met here did not stop at one page. Read them whole; walk a passage through the week; keep your own words beside theirs.

Explore the Shelf