Questioningthe weight and the grace
crying in darkness, then remembering what God has done
Where we are
A man cannot sleep, and he says it is God who is holding his eyes open. He has prayed all night with his hand out, and no comfort has come. He asks his questions aloud, and the psalm lets him.
This week's word
“Asaph cries out to God in a day of trouble. All night his hand is stretched out in prayer, and his soul refuses comfort; remembering God only makes him groan. He cannot sleep and cannot speak. He thinks of the old days, and of the songs he used to sing at night, and his spirit asks: Will the Lord reject us forever? Has his loving kindness come to an end? Has God forgotten to be gracious? Then he resolves to appeal to "the years of the right hand of the Most High," and to remember, and turn over in his heart, all that God has done.”
paraphrase
Reflection
All night the hand stays up. "My hand was stretched out in the night, and didn’t get tired." Alexander Maclaren, reading the psalm closely, notices that both verbs belong to tears. "Stretched out" is literally poured out, as water, a word Lamentations uses of weeping eyes; and where we read that the hand did not tire, Maclaren gives the words as "grew not stiff," a phrase also used of tears that will not stop. The hand weeps. It is held out all night, and the psalm never says that anything was put in it.
Then comes a line few of us would dare to pray: "You hold my eyelids open." It is more than sleeplessness. He says God will not let him sleep; Maclaren pictures him feeling "as if God's finger was pushing up his lids and forcing him to stare out into the night." It is a hard thing to say to God, and Asaph says it to his face, which is already a kind of faith: the sleeplessness is laid before God because there is no one else to lay it before. "I am so troubled that I can’t speak," he says, and yet the whole psalm is speech, and speech to God. It opened with a cry: "My cry goes to God! Indeed, I cry to God for help, and for him to listen to me." A trouble too deep for words has been put into words, and the words have been sent where they belong.
Memory does not help him at first. "I remember God, and I groan." He remembers more than God: "I remember my song in the night." The songs he once sang on other nights now stand against this one. So the remembering turns into questions, six of them, asked in the open, and after them a Selah, a pause, as though the psalm would have them stand a while before anyone answers. They are the spirit's diligent inquiry, and the psalm does not rebuke them.
The questions are made of particular words: loving kindness, gracious, anger, compassion. They are the words of the name God proclaimed to Moses on the mountain as he passed by him: merciful and gracious, slow to anger, abounding in loving kindness (). Asaph is not inventing doubts in the dark. He is holding God's own name up to the night and asking whether it is still true. "All the questions," Maclaren writes, "mean substantially one thing—has God changed?" Only someone who believed the name could ask it. Doubt that has never heard the name has nothing to hold up.
Jacob Behmen went through such a night. Alexander Whyte, retelling Behmen's own account of it, reaches for Asaph, the name over this psalm, though he is thinking of another of Asaph's, the seventy-third. The misery of the world, Whyte says, cast Behmen into "a deep and inconsolable melancholy," and then he writes the sentence that belongs beside the soul that refused comfort: "No Scripture could comfort him." is Scripture for the night when no Scripture comforts. It does not argue. It sits up with us. What Behmen did, Whyte says, was to wrap "his whole heart, and mind, and will, and desire in the love and the mercy of God: determined not to give over till God had heard him and had helped him." There is the hand that does not tire.
Then Asaph decides. "I will appeal to this: the years of the right hand of the Most High." Twice he has said "I remember," and both times it hurt. Now the tense changes, and the change is a resolve: "I will remember Yah’s deeds; for I will remember your wonders of old." The soul that refused to be comforted chooses to meditate. He does not say he is comforted. He goes to the sea. "Your way was through the sea; your paths through the great waters. Your footsteps were not known." Israel walked on dry ground between the waters (), and no one saw the prints of the God who made the road.
The name and the sea meet once more, long afterwards. Mark tells of a night when the disciples were straining at the oars against the wind, and Jesus came to them walking on the sea, and meant, Mark says, to pass by them (). It is what the Lord did on the mountain when he proclaimed his name to Moses: he passed by. They saw him and cried out, not knowing him (). Mark goes on to tell what Jesus said to them. Asaph's psalm does not get that far.
Its last line puts God's hand where it could be seen: "You led your people like a flock, by the hand of Moses and Aaron." And there it stops. Once he begins to tell God about the sea, the "I" that cried all night does not come back. We are not told whether he slept, or whether the questions were answered, or whether the next night was any different. The psalm ends with a flock walking out of the water and footprints no one saw, and it leaves us where it left him: the hand still up, and nothing to appeal to but the years when the Most High stretched out his own.
Sit with
What question have we been afraid to ask God aloud?
Your own words belong here too — what you are sitting with, a prayer, a line to carry. A free account keeps them beside this devotional, and gathers each week's into your Notebook.
Begin herePrayer
Most High, why do you hold our eyelids open? Our hands have been out all night, and there is nothing in them. Will you reject us forever? Have you forgotten to be gracious? We ask because you told us your name, and we are holding you to it. We will remember the sea, though no one saw your footsteps there, and we cannot see them now. If you lead us, lead us as you led them, by hands we can see. Amen.
Carry into the week
Hold his own name up to the night.
Pass it on
Send this to someone walking with you. The card that travels with the link carries one of its lines.Or select any line above, and that one travels instead.
Draws on
Every voice named above comes from the Dia Logos Library — public domain, read in full. Nothing is attributed that cannot be opened.
This week in the chorus
Elsewhere in the chorus
Dia Logos — the chorus of the Church, speaking across time, in dialogue with each other, with Scripture, and with you.
The voices you met here did not stop at one page. Read them whole; walk a passage through the week; keep your own words beside theirs.