Questioningthe quiet persistence
the lament that will not be silenced
Where we are
Psalm 88 is the prayer of a man who believes he is as good as dead, and who prays anyway. From its first line to its last, no answer comes.
This week's word
“Heman cries to the God of his salvation by day and by night, and asks only that his prayer be let in. He says he is as good as dead already: laid in the lowest pit, swept over by God's waves, shut in where he cannot get out, his friends turned away from him. He asks whether the dead can praise God, and whether God's kindness is spoken of in the grave. Each morning he prays again, and asks why God hides his face. The psalm ends with no answer, lover and friend far off, and the word "darkness."”
paraphrase
Reflection
Someone wrote music for this. The heading of is easy to skip, a cluster of old instructions, but read slowly it startles. The psalm is marked "For the Chief Musician" and set to a tune called "The Suffering of Affliction." A man prayed a prayer with no answer in it, and the people of God did not tuck it away. They gave it to the choir. Someone tuned instruments for it. A congregation learned how it went.
It is credited, too, to the sons of Korah. Numbers remembers Korah as a rebel the earth opened and swallowed (; 26:10), and adds that his sons did not die (); Chronicles traces the line of a temple singer named Heman back to him (). The family that kept this song had a pit in its memory. "I am counted among those who go down into the pit", the psalm says, and it reaches us through the children of the spared.
Alexander Maclaren, writing on the Psalter, calls it "an anomaly." "All but unbroken gloom broods over it, and is densest at its close." It opens with "Yahweh, the God of my salvation" and closes on darkness, and nowhere between is there a turn, a vow of praise, a hinge of hope. Maclaren is moved by it all the same. He sees in it a "trust which has ceased to ask or hope for the removal of lifelong griefs, but still clasps God's hand". In that opening name he finds "the one star which gleams for a moment through a rift in the blackness."
But he also says something we should press. "Such experience is comparatively rare, and is meant to be risen above." Is it rare? Johann Arndt, writing to comfort those in deep spiritual distress, did not treat it so. He urged them "to repeat frequently, with lively affection, the 88th Psalm, where thou wilt see the state of thy soul described." He prescribed it the way a physician prescribes a medicine, to be taken often. And his reason goes to the heart of what this psalm does for a people: "There thou wilt find that there have been others in the world before thee, who have been tried and afflicted as thou art".
The lonely cannot know this from inside the dark: the dark has been prayed before. That is a true gift, but it is not the deepest thing in the psalm. Heman's wound is turned toward God. "Yahweh, why do you reject my soul? Why do you hide your face from me?" Even his loneliness among people he lays at God's door: "You have taken my friends from me." "You have put lover and friend far from me". No choir can answer the hidden face, and no congregation should pretend to. What a singing people can give is company inside the question, not an end to it.
Arndt, having given that gift, does not stay long in the dark. In the next breath he turns to and its song of the Lord's mercies; he is writing to comfort, and he wants the afflicted to see the page turn. The psalm itself does not turn it. And , for all its singing, comes round near its close to asking the Lord where his former loving kindnesses have gone (). The Psalter does not resolve Heman. It keeps him.
The Way of Jesus runs through this psalm, not around it. In Gethsemane he asked three friends to stay awake with him while his soul was sorrowful to the point of death, and they slept (). On the cross he prayed out of the hidden face itself, asking God why he had forsaken him (). Those who follow him are given no explanation to hand to Heman. They are asked to stay awake: to be the friends he lost, and to sing his dark song with him, to the tune it was given.
Maclaren noticed that the cry comes three times: "I have cried day and night before you"; "I have called on you daily, Yahweh"; "In the morning, my prayer comes before you." Nothing comes back. Every morning the prayer goes out again. "All the more admirable, then," Maclaren writes, "the persistence of his cry". This faith has no feeling to lean on and no relief in view. What it has is the next morning's prayer and a name, the God of my salvation, and saying that name into the dark is the hope it has left.
We may know more than Heman knew about the grave and what God would do there. That knowledge is not ours to lay over his mouth. The Church that knows Easter still keeps this psalm in its book and sings it to the last line. Some nights the most faithful thing a people can do is refuse to skip to the end.
The last word of the psalm is "darkness," and nothing we say should move it. What we can do is be there in the morning when the prayer goes up again, and ask it with the one who is asking: "Why do you hide your face from me?" Asked together, it is still unanswered. But no one has to ask it alone.
Sit with
Can we stay with a prayer that has no answer yet, without hurrying it to the end?
Your own words belong here too — what you are sitting with, a prayer, a line to carry. A free account keeps them beside this devotional, and gathers each week's into your Notebook.
Begin herePrayer
God of our salvation, we cry to you by day and by night, and some nights nothing comes back. Let our prayer come into your presence. Turn your ear to us. We do not understand why you hide your face. We bring you the ones who are asking that tonight: those shut in by illness, by grief, by a mind that will not lift, those whose friends have gone. We do not ask you to explain yourself to them. We ask you to turn your face toward them, and until you do, to make us their friends. Keep us awake in the garden. And if our own morning comes with no answer, we will bring our prayer before you again, because you are still the God of our salvation. Hear us.
Carry into the week
The question goes up again tomorrow, and we go with it.
Pass it on
Send this to someone walking with you. The card that travels with the link carries one of its lines.Or select any line above, and that one travels instead.
Draws on
Every voice named above comes from the Dia Logos Library — public domain, read in full. Nothing is attributed that cannot be opened.
This week in the chorus
Elsewhere in the chorus
Dia Logos — the chorus of the Church, speaking across time, in dialogue with each other, with Scripture, and with you.
The voices you met here did not stop at one page. Read them whole; walk a passage through the week; keep your own words beside theirs.