On the ancient themesyou are not alone, and never were
The Communion of Saints
Father, we are surrounded.
The word stands at the top of the page in Hebrews and will not move: surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses (). We did not gather them. We did not summon them. We opened the book this morning and found that we had already been encircled before we knew to ask.
Father, we have been told, and we half-believe, that the people who loved You before us are not gone. That a grandmother, sent for to the stake to hear her granddaughter say her faith one last time, is not finished. That the shoemaker who prayed for the preacher on the way to the stake is somewhere still at prayer. That the elder writing letters to a bereaved mother did not stop writing when the ink dried. We have been told this. We say it in the creed. I believe in the communion of saints. We say it quickly, between the holy catholic Church and the forgiveness of sins, and move on, and we hardly notice that the saints and the forgiveness have been seated side by side.
But here, at the opening of , the writer slows us. He has just finished naming them — Abel, Enoch, Noah, Abraham, Sarah, Moses, Rahab, the ones sawn in two, the ones who wandered in sheepskins — and now, having named them, he lifts his eyes and tells us they are all around us. Therefore let us also, seeing we are surrounded by so great a cloud of witnesses, lay aside every weight… and let us run with perseverance the race that is set before us, looking to Jesus ().
Father, we come to this passage with a quiet question. Who are these witnesses to us? Are they a memory we honor, or a company we join? When we pray tonight in a room that looks empty, is the room empty?
We confess we have often lived as if it were. We have treated the faith as a solitary transaction between our small soul and Your large mercy, forgetting the vast assembly that was praying us into existence. We have grieved as those who had no neighbors. We have run as though there were no track and no stands, no one before us who finished, no one behind us pressing in.
Open the eyes of our heart, Father. Let us see what the dying see. Let us know what the martyrs knew. Let us hear what a grieving mother heard when she was told that her strong Saviour bore the weightiest end of her cross.
Hand us, Lord, into the chorus. We have overheard a rumour that we are not alone, and never were. Let the rumour become sight.
The writer of Hebrews has a strange grammar. He does not say remember the witnesses. He does not say imitate them, though that will come. He says we are surrounded by them — perikeimenon, lying all around us, encircling us on every side. The image is a stadium, and we are the runners, and the stands are full.
Full of whom?
The chapter before has told us. Abel, who still speaks though he is dead. Enoch, taken away so that he would not see death. Noah, warned of things not yet seen. Abraham, going out, not knowing where he was going. Sarah, past the age. Moses, choosing to suffer with the people of God. Rahab, whom Hebrews does not trouble to make respectable: "By faith, Rahab the prostitute, didn't perish with those who were disobedient" (), and whom Matthew sets in the Son's own family tree: "Salmon became the father of Boaz by Rahab" (). And then, with the air gathering urgency, the ones who were tortured, mocked, scourged, stoned, sawn asunder, slain with the sword — of whom the world was not worthy ().
These are the witnesses. These are the ones already in the stands. And the Scripture refuses to let them stay abstract. It names them. One after another. The whole weight of is that the cloud has faces. And each face is first a face God has spoken for: "These all, having had testimony given to them through their faith, didn't receive the promise, God having provided some better thing concerning us, so that apart from us they should not be made perfect" (). They are not finished without us.
Take one face. By faith, Enoch was taken away, so that he wouldn't see death, and he was not found, because God translated him (). Luther, lecturing on Genesis, stops at that disappearance and imagines what it was like for the family. At first there was only the missing man: it was appalling to them to hear that so holy a man as Enoch had disappeared so completely that his whereabouts or manner of death was beyond everybody's ken. Great, therefore, was the grief of the pious parents and elders. But afterwards incredible joy and consolation were theirs when they heard that their son lived with God himself and had been translated by God to an angelic and eternal life.
He follows the news to old Seth, being now an old man and full of days, whose father Adam had fallen asleep fifty-seven years before, and who now hears that Enoch is not dead but taken. Luther sees him spending his last years among his family: In this manner, doubtless, the aged saint employed his time among his descendants, bidding farewell to and blessing each one. And Luther cannot help putting himself in the old man's place. If I knew that I were appointed to die in six months' time, I should scarcely find time enough wherein to make my will. He gives Seth a sermon for his family: Let us look forward with continual sighs to that true life to which, my children, your brother Enoch has been translated by the glorious God.
The communion begins there — in a family that thought it had lost someone, and was told he had only been moved to the other side of the stadium. It is one of the first things Genesis tells us: the saints who have gone are not gone. Hebrews says Enoch was translated; Luther says the Hebrew means he was received to himself.
But Enoch did not see death, and almost no one else is spared it. The saints died. The One at the finish died. Hebrews says he was made a little lower than the angels "that by the grace of God he should taste of death for everyone" (). Enoch is a sign held up early in the story. The road through death is the one the Son walked.
Gregory the Great tells a story in his Dialogues that reads like a footnote to . An abbot named Stephen told it to him. In the province of Nursia there was a priest named Ursinus, forty years in orders, who lay dying of a fever. His wife bent down to see if he still breathed, and he sent her from the room. And then, after she had gone, his strength rising a little, he broke out with great joy: Welcome, my Lords, welcome, my Lords: why have you vouchsafed to visit me, your unworthy servant? I come, I come: I thank you, I thank you.
His friends asked him whom he was speaking to. He answered them in wonder. What? do you not here behold the holy Apostles? Do you not see the chief of them, St. Peter and St. Paul? Then he turned back toward the Apostles. Behold I come, behold I come. And with those words he died.
Gregory says what he thinks it means, and it is in a sickroom: good men at their death do behold his Saints going before them, and leading as it were the way, to the end they should not be afraid at the pangs thereof. In the next chapter he tells of a bishop named Probus, dying while his old father and the physicians were at dinner upstairs, with only a small boy left by the bed. Upstairs there was a meal. Downstairs there was a dying man and a child standing by the bed, the only one left with him. The boy suddenly saw certain men coming in to the man of God, apparelled in white stoles, whose faces were far more beautiful and bright than the whiteness of their garments. He was frightened and began to cry out. The bishop looked up and knew them, and comforted the child: they were martyrs, he told him, come to visit. But the boy could not bear it, and ran out at the doors as fast as he could for the others. When they came down, the bishop was gone.
The cloud, Gregory wants us to understand, is not only watching. At certain hinges, by God's permission, it leans down. The dying man is not making a speech. He is answering a greeting.
Scripture has its own deathbed of this kind, and it shows whose greeting it finally is. Stephen, before the first stone, "looked up steadfastly into heaven, and saw the glory of God, and Jesus standing on the right hand of God" (). The saints go before. The Son stands up. "Lord Jesus, receive my spirit!" ().
And yet most of us have not seen this. We have sat by a bed through a long night and no one came that we could see. The breathing changed, and slowed, and stopped. No one said Welcome, my Lords. The nurse came in quietly and turned off the machine, and the room was a room, and we went home to a house with one less person in it. If the cloud leaned down, it did not let us see it.
Stay there a moment. Hebrews does not say we will see them. It says something stranger, and says it as already done: "But you have come to Mount Zion, and to the city of the living God, the heavenly Jerusalem, and to innumerable multitudes of angels, to the festal gathering and assembly of the firstborn who are enrolled in heaven, to God the Judge of all, to the spirits of just men made perfect, to Jesus, the mediator of a new covenant, and to the blood of sprinkling that speaks better than that of Abel" (). You have come. Not you will see. The room we thought was empty was already the edge of a festal gathering, whether we saw it or not.
Looking to Jesus, the author and perfecter of faith.
The runner, Hebrews says, does not keep his eyes on the stands. The stands are the gift of being seen; the runner's gaze is fixed on the One at the finish, who ran this track first and sits now at the right hand of the throne of God. The communion of saints does not compete with Christ. The communion of saints is made by Christ — the body knit to its Head.
Paul says this in another key.
There is one body, and one Spirit, even as you also were called in one hope of your calling; one Lord, one faith, one baptism, one God and Father of all, who is over all, and through all, and in us all ().
Hear how Paul lays down the ones. One body. One Spirit. One hope. One Lord. One faith. One baptism. One God and Father. Seven times he strikes the same note, and we begin to understand that the Church is a single thing. Not a federation of souls. Not a club of the like-minded. A body. And a body is not divided by the generations through which it passes. The hand that blessed a preacher at Coventry in 1555 and the hand that writes a letter tonight belong to the same body, because they belong to the same Head.
From whom all the body, being fitted and knit together through that which every joint supplies… makes the body increase to the building up of itself in love ().
Thomas à Kempis sees this at the altar. In the last book of the Imitation, the disciple comes to Communion and finds himself unable to come alone. He says to God: With the deepest devotion and fervent love, with all affection and fervour of heart, I long to receive Thee, O Lord, even as many Saints and devout persons have desired Thee in communicating, who were altogether well pleasing to Thee by their sanctity of life, and dwelt in all ardent devotion. The disciple cannot muster, from his own thin heart, enough love to meet the gift. So he borrows. He reaches for Mary, who answered the angel Behold the handmaid of the Lord, and for John the Baptist, who leapt while yet in the womb of his mother. He brings the people he has promised to pray for: on behalf of myself and of all commended to me in prayer, I offer and present unto Thee the jubilation of all devout hearts. And he calls the whole Church to the table with him: With beseechings and affectionate desires I call upon all celestial spirits and all Thy faithful people to join with me in rendering Thee thanks and praises.
Then he asks the ones beside him at the table for something. And let all who reverently and devoutly celebrate Thy most high Sacrament … intercede with all supplication for me a sinner; and when they shall have attained unto their wished-for devotion and joyous union with Thee … let them vouchsafe to be mindful of me, for I am poor and needy.
He is praying with them, and asking them to remember him. The altar is where the stadium becomes a sanctuary and the runners become a choir.
Elsewhere in the book, Thomas confesses a weariness: even spiritual comfort whatsoever it be becometh sore weariness to me; for so long as I see not openly my Lord in His own Glory, I count for nothing all which I behold and hear in the world.
Some of us know that weariness as a season. We pray at the same hour every night and say the same words, and nothing stirs. Not for an evening; for months, for a year. The room looks empty and stays empty. We keep coming, and we wonder whether coming without feeling is a kind of pretending, and we would rather not say so, even to God.
Thomas does not pretend, and he does not stop. He leans on the saints, who waited for the coming of Thy glory whilst they lived here: What they believed, that believe I; what they hoped, I hope; whither they have attained to, thither through Thy grace hope I to come. I will walk meanwhile in faith, strengthened by the examples of the Saints. He does not blush to say so. He knows the body carries him when his own joint has gone slack.
Lay aside every weight and the sin which so easily entangles us.
The runner's track is cleared by the ones who ran before. We did not invent the way. The way has been worn by feet. When our feet falter, we are falling into tracks older than we are.
John Foxe, writing in the shadow of fires he could still smell, gives us the cloud with English names. Laurence Saunders was a London preacher, at All-hallows in Bread Street, and on a Sunday afternoon in October he was taken out of his own church while he was reading to his people. He was kept in prison, Foxe says, one year and a quarter. When at last they condemned him, they put him in the Compter, a prison in his own parish, and Foxe says he rejoiced greatly at it, because out of prison, as before in his pulpit, he might have an opportunity of preaching to his parishioners.
Then they took him to Coventry to be burned. When they had arrived at Coventry, a poor shoemaker, who used to serve him with shoes, came to him, and said, O my good master, God strengthen and comfort you. Good shoemaker, Saunders answered, I desire thee to pray for me, for I am the most unfit man for this high office, that ever was appointed to it; but my gracious God and dear Father is able to make me strong enough.
The shoemaker and the preacher. One body. One Spirit. The one about to die asks the one who will go on living to pray for him — and the one who will go on living has already blessed him. This is on the eve of a burning. And the shoemaker is the one left holding the prayer he had been asked for. Foxe does not say what became of him. Most of us are the shoemaker.
The next day the man the shoemaker had shod went out in an old gown and a shirt, bare-footed, and oftentimes fell flat on the ground, and prayed. Near the place, an officer offered him pardon if he would recant. Not I, he said, but such as you have injured the realm. And then Foxe gives the moment the whole story leans toward: Mr. Saunders then slowly moved towards the fire, sank to the earth and prayed; he then rose up, embraced the stake, and frequently said, "Welcome, thou cross of Christ! welcome everlasting life!"
Welcome. It is the same word the priest in Nursia cried before he died. One welcomed the saints who had come for him; the other welcomed the cross that would take him to them. And Foxe ends the way the old books end: he sweetly slept in the Lord Jesus.
Foxe lingers too over a letter written by Richard Roth, in blood, to friends facing the same fire. He was waiting his own turn, and he tells them where: I lie in my lord's Little-ease by day, and in the night I lie in the Coal-house. He had been told he would burn within ten days before Easter, and still the day did not come. But I lie still at the pool's brink, and every man goeth in before me.
Lie there with him a while. The day comes and goes. The others go in before him, and he is still lying in the Coal-house at night, waiting. It is the man at Bethesda, who had been sick for thirty-eight years (): Sir, I have no one to put me into the pool when the water is stirred up, but while I'm coming, another steps down before me ().
Read the verse between, and the complaint changes where it stands. When Jesus saw him lying there, and knew that he had been sick for a long time, he asked him, Do you want to be made well? (). He said I have no one to the One who had already seen him lying there.
In Roth's letter the next words are these: but we abide patiently the Lord's leisure. He had dear hearts to write to, and a Saviour at the brink.
And then he looks past the fire. O dear hearts, you shall be clothed in long white garments upon the mount of Sion, with the multitude of saints, and with Jesus Christ our Saviour, who will never forsake us. Roth writes as if from inside . O dear hearts, how precious shall your death be in the sight of the Lord! for dear is the death of his saints. O fare you well, and pray. The grace of our Lord Jesus Christ be with you all. Amen, Amen. Pray, pray, pray!
And then, above his name: Written by me, with my own blood.
John looks up and sees them.
After these things I looked, and behold, a great multitude, which no man could count, out of every nation and of all tribes, peoples, and languages, standing before the throne and before the Lamb, dressed in white robes, with palm branches in their hands ().
Richard Roth, writing to his dear hearts in his own blood, is already describing what John has already seen. Foxe records what Roth wrote, and we read, nearly five centuries further on, and the three of us — John on Patmos, Roth at his letter, we at the kitchen table — are looking at the same multitude. The multitude includes Roth now. It has room for us, whoever we are, and however late we come.
These are those who came out of the great tribulation. They washed their robes, and made them white in the Lamb's blood ().
Washed white, Scripture says, in blood. The strange chemistry of the Gospel. The martyr's blood does not whiten the robe; the Lamb's blood does. The witnesses are witnesses because they were first witnessed-for. The runners run because One ran before them. So the creed is right to seat the communion of saints beside the forgiveness of sins: there is no one in the stands who was not first forgiven.
Foxe keeps writing names. George Tankerfield, cook, aged 27. Robert Smith, who, half burnt and supposed dead, suddenly rose up, moved what was left of his arms, and praised God.
And at the very end of that reign, the last five. Foxe says they earnestly prayed that their blood might be the last shed, nor did they pray in vain, and that they perfected the number God had selected to hear witness of the truth in this dreadful reign, whose names are recorded in the Book of Life — though last, not least among the saints made meet for immortality through the redeeming blood of the Lamb. Foxe tells of two women among them. Catharine Finlay had been first converted by her son's expounding the Scriptures to her. And Alice Snoth, at the stake, sent for her grandmother and godfather, and rehearsed to them the articles of her faith, and the commandments of God. Stand there with her. Before she speaks to the crowd, she sends for her grandmother, and for her godfather, who would have answered for her at the font when she was too small to say the words, and she says them back to them herself, as if to say: you gave me this, and I have kept it. Then she died calling upon the spectators to bear witness that she was a Christian woman.
Last, not least. Hebrews is quietly undoing our rank. The one who died in 1555 is not senior to the one who dies this year. The stadium does not have tiers of honour; it has one throne, and one Lamb, and one great multitude.
Chesterton, in the book where he tells how he came to believe, gave the stands a name. Tradition means giving votes to the most obscure of all classes, our ancestors. It is the democracy of the dead. Tradition refuses to submit to the small and arrogant oligarchy of those who merely happen to be walking about. He goes on: All democrats object to men being disqualified by the accident of birth; tradition objects to their being disqualified by the accident of death. And then, as plainly as he ever said anything: We will have the dead at our councils.
A cook born at York, aged 27, has a vote. A shoemaker has a vote. A woman who said her creed to her grandmother at the stake has a vote. And the vote is not cast in silence. The ones in the white robes are crying out with a loud voice. Salvation be to our God, who sits on the throne, and to the Lamb! (). The stadium is loud, even on the nights we hear nothing.
Rutherford writes into the furnace, to a woman whose daughter has died. He had come away from her, and the letter begins with that: I was indeed sorrowful at my departure from you, especially since ye were in such heaviness after your daughter's death. Then the sentence at the heart of the letter: Yet I do persuade myself, ye know that the weightiest end of the cross of Christ that is laid upon you lieth upon your strong Saviour; for Isaiah saith, "In all your afflictions He is afflicted." He means Isaiah's In all their affliction he was afflicted (), and he cannot stay in the sentence for joy at it: O blessed Second who suffereth with you! and glad may your soul be even to walk in the fiery furnace with one like unto the Son of Man, who is also the Son of God. The furnace is crowded. One like unto the Son of Man walks with her, as he walked with the three in Babylon.
He does not know how old the girl was. If she was eighteen, nineteen, or twenty years old, I know not. But he knows where she is, and he tells her mother plainly. Do you think her lost, when she is but sleeping in the bosom of the Almighty? Think her not absent who is in such a friend's house. Is she lost to you who is found to Christ?
Think her not absent who is in such a friend's house.
Later in the letter: you are nearer your daughter this day than you were yesterday. And then 's own charge, said to a mother: Run your race with patience.
He does not tell her the grief is small. He tells her where her daughter is, and that every day brings her nearer.
To another friend in another trial Rutherford writes: Neither is this your condition alone, but the experienced lot of all the saints that have gone before you. It is one and the same cross of Christ; but there be sundry faces and diverse circumstances in the same remnant (Col. i. 24), the sufferings of Christ and yours. The same cross. The same race. Sundry faces. The remnant is one. The verse in his brackets is Paul's, written in chains for a church he had never seen: "Now I rejoice in my sufferings for your sake, and fill up on my part that which is lacking of the afflictions of Christ in my flesh for his body's sake, which is the assembly" ().
And when he must say goodbye in paper, perhaps forever, Rutherford writes: to my grief I must bid you (it may be, for ever) farewell, in paper, having small assurance ever to see your face again till the last general assembly, where the whole church universal shall meet.
The last general assembly.
Rutherford is echoing Hebrews itself; the old English Bibles read there "the general assembly and church of the firstborn". It is the Church's name for 's stadium. We are not running toward a trophy; we are running toward an assembly. The ones already seated are not spectators; they are early arrivals. The hall is being filled.
Bunyan, in a book on the love of Christ, catches the quiet mechanism of it: as a forerunner, he is gone into heaven to take possession thereof for us: there to make ready, and to prepare for us our summer-houses, our mansion, dwelling-places. As if we were the lords, and he the servant! It is Hebrews' as a forerunner Jesus entered for us () and the Son's own I am going to prepare a place for you (). The Head has gone ahead. The body is following. The communion is a procession, and the One at its head has turned around to make the beds for those still on the way.
And in the same list Bunyan says what the forerunner still feels from where he is: Nothing can happen to his people to hurt them, but he feels it, is touched with it, and counteth it as done unto himself: Yea, sympathizes with them, and is afflicted, and grieved in their griefs. It is Rutherford's verse again, from the other side.
And it is a word for the one whose feeling has gone. When we cannot feel, the Head still can, and our griefs are felt where we cannot feel them.
Looking to Jesus, the author and perfecter of faith, who for the joy that was set before him endured the cross, despising its shame, and has sat down at the right hand of the throne of God.
He endured for a joy. Hebrews has already said what it was: God was "bringing many children to glory" (), and the Son stands among them and says to the Father, "Behold, here I am with the children whom God has given me" (). The joy was the children the Father gave him. The joy was the great multitude that no man could count. The joy was Enoch and Seth and Ursinus, Laurence Saunders and the shoemaker who prayed for him, Roth at the pool's brink, the daughter in her friend's house, and whoever is reading this tonight, alone at a table or together in a room. All of us, together, were the joy set before Him.
Hebrews gathers it all into a single verb: run.
Run with perseverance. Run with the saints at your shoulder — the ones Hebrews names, the ones Foxe names, and the ones whose names only God has kept. Run with the ones you buried, who are in such a friend's house. Run with the great multitude in white robes, with palm branches, under the spreading tabernacle, led to the springs.
Run looking to Jesus.
Not looking at them. Looking with them. All of us together looking in the one direction, toward the One who sat down because the race was finished and now waits for the rest of His body to arrive.
Lord Jesus, author and perfecter of our faith, we place the question before You where we found it.
Who are these witnesses to us? Are the saints a memory or a company? When we pray tonight, is the room empty?
We do not ask You to answer in words. You have already answered in and in and in the long patient fact that Your Church is still here. We ask You to answer in the eyes of our heart. Let us see what the dying priest saw when he said, Welcome, my Lords. Let us hear what the grieving mother heard. Let us know ourselves surrounded.
Father, we think tonight of the ones we loved who went ahead of us. The mother or father we still reach for the phone to call. The grandmother who prayed us by name before we could pray. The friend whose funeral we attended last year, or last week. The child who went so soon. We have carried their absence like a weight. Teach us, Lord, to know also their presence — not as a sentiment we manufacture, but as a fact of the body You have made, true on the nights we feel it and true on the nights we feel nothing at all. Think them not absent who are in such a friend's house. They are at the last general assembly, waiting. They are among the great multitude that no man can count, and You are in the middle of the throne, and You shepherd them, and You will shepherd us when it is our turn to arrive. We do not know all that they do there, or whether they still pray for us as they did here. We know whose house they are in.
And some of the ones we have lost are still alive: the marriage that ended, the child who will not call, the friend who walked away. Hold them in the body too. The absence of the living is its own grief, and You know it.
Holy Spirit, where our joint has gone slack, carry us by the joints that are strong: the friend who sent us this, the ones sitting with us tonight, the old man in the next pew who has never once missed. Perhaps he feels no more than we do. Teach us from him that a dry joint can still hold, and let us hold someone too. Where our longing is too thin to come to the altar on its own, gather for us the longings of Thomas at his altar and the shoemaker of Coventry and Seth among his grandchildren, and let us borrow until we can give. Where our fear closes the room, open it. Where our grief insists we are alone, break the lie gently.
What stays open is sight. We have been told the room is full; we have not been shown it, and we will not pretend we have. We will walk out of this hour still asking, and the asking will be prayer.
Only this, Lord. When the day comes that we lie as the old priest lay, and some kind soul bends down to see if we still breathe, let there be breath enough left to say what he said. Welcome, my Lords. Welcome, my Lords. Why have you vouchsafed to visit me, your unworthy servant? I come, I come. And if our road goes the way Saunders went, let us say his word to the cross: welcome. And if there is no breath left, and no words, and no one bends down at all, receive us anyway, as surely as You received the priest in Nursia. Let the last face we see be Yours, standing to meet us.
Until that hour, keep us running. Keep our eyes on You. Keep our ears open to the stands. And send us home to our benches and our kitchens carrying the prayers we have been asked for, as the shoemaker of Coventry was asked for his.
God will wipe away every tear from their eyes ().
Hold the promise over us, Lord, as a tabernacle spread. We are not alone. We never were.
Amen.
The silence is yours. A free account keeps whatever rises in it here, beside this reflection, and in your Notebook.
Begin herePass it on
Send this to someone walking with you. The card that travels with the link carries one of its lines.Or select any line above, and that one travels instead.
Draws on
Every voice named above comes from the Dia Logos Library — public domain, read in full. Nothing is attributed that cannot be opened.
Elsewhere in the chorus
Dia Logos — the chorus of the Church, speaking across time, in dialogue with each other, with Scripture, and with you.
The voices you met here did not stop at one page. Read them whole; walk a passage through the week; keep your own words beside theirs.