Skip to main content
Dia Logos

On the ancient themesthe fellowship of his sufferings

Watch with Me


Lord Jesus, you asked three friends to stay awake with you, and they slept.

You had told them what kind of night it was: "My soul is exceedingly sorrowful, even to death. Stay here, and watch with me" (). Then you went forward a little and fell on your face, and prayed while Peter and the sons of Zebedee breathed slowly in the dark behind you.

Your apostle, writing later in chains, asked for the very thing they slept through. "I count all things to be a loss for the excellency of the knowledge of Christ Jesus, my Lord," he wrote, "that I may know him, and the power of his resurrection, and the fellowship of his sufferings, becoming conformed to his death" (, 10).

He asked for it. Most of us did not. It came anyway, a watch no one had warned us about, and some of us could still draw the room. The corridor outside had half its lights turned down after midnight. The chair beside the bed was made for a visit of twenty minutes, and we sat in it all night. A small pink sponge on a stick stood in a cup of water, and every so often we wet the lips that could no longer ask for it. And there was the breathing: one breath, then a gap long enough for the whole room to listen, then another. We stayed awake because someone had to, and somewhere after three we slept anyway, and woke with a start to the same breathing, and were ashamed. Then, one night, the gap did not end.

Afterwards we said what Martha said on the road into Bethany, that if you had been there her brother would not have died (). Her sister said the same sentence, word for word. You gave neither of them a reason for staying away. You asked, "Where have you laid him?" and then you wept ().

We have not come for a reason either. Let us know you here, where the watch is kept.

She asked for it, as Paul had. A young woman asked God for a sickness that would take her to the edge of death, and for a sight of the Passion, because she wished she had stood on the hill with Mary Magdalene and the others who loved him. "For I would be one of them and suffer with Him," Julian of Norwich writes.

At thirty and a half she got the sickness. On the fourth night she was given the last rites. Three nights later the people at her bedside thought she was going, and so did she, and by morning she could feel nothing below the waist. She had them prop her up, and the curate came and held a crucifix in front of her face. Her eyes had been fixed on heaven. She moved them to the crucifix because, she says, she could hold her gaze longer "even-forth than right up." Then her sight failed, and the room went as dark as night, except for the cross. On the cross there was "a common light," and she could not say where it came from.

A common light, on one thing. The people around her bed were watching her die, and she was watching him. In that light she saw the blood come from under the crown of thorns, thick as "the drops of water that fall off the eaves after a great shower of rain," and, where it spread on the forehead, round "like to the scale of herring."

She kept looking. She watched his face go "dry and bloodless with pale dying," and then "more dead unto blue," while a dry, cold wind dried the body on the cross, and by then, she says, she wished she had never asked. "Of all pains that lead to salvation this is the most pain, to see thy Love suffer."

Her own good sense offered her a way out: "Look up to Heaven to His Father." She would not move her eyes. "Nay; I may not: for Thou art my Heaven." The part of her that had flinched and wished it over, she was shown, is a frailty "to which God assigneth no blame."

When the fifteenth showing ended, the pain came back "with a sound and a din," and she told a visitor she had raved. He laughed out loud. Then she said, "The Cross that stood afore my face, methought it bled fast," and he stopped laughing, and she wept for shame. "How should a priest believe me? I believe not our Lord God."

Another young woman asked to keep watch, and was sent to bed. On the night before Good Friday a watch was kept at the Altar of Repose through the hour that Peter and James and John had slept away, and Thérèse of Lisieux "could not obtain permission to remain watching" there till morning. She was twenty-three. At midnight she went back to her cell, put out the lamp and lay down. "Scarcely was my head laid on the pillow when I felt a hot stream rise to my lips."

She thought she was dying, and her heart "nearly broke with joy." The lamp was out, and she did not light it again; she lay in the dark and slept until morning. At five she went to the window and found the handkerchief "soaked with blood." It was tuberculosis. It would kill her eighteen months later, at twenty-four.

That Good Friday evening her faith was so clear that she was sure anyone who denied heaven was lying. She had asked for one night's watch. What came at Easter she had never asked for. The thought of heaven, which had comforted her since she was small, went dark and turned on her. She compared herself to a child born "in a land of thick fogs," who has never seen the sun and has only been told of it, and she knew who else had lived in that country: "the King of that sunlit country dwelt for three and thirty years in the land of darkness." Out of the fog she seemed to hear a voice promising that death would give her "not what you hope for, but a night darker still, the night of utter nothingness!"

Anyone reading the poems she wrote that year, she told her prioress, would think her flooded with consolation. "And yet it is not a veil—it is a wall which rises to the very heavens and shuts out the starry sky." When she sang of heaven she felt nothing at all: "I sing only of what I wish to believe." Now and then a little light got through, and afterwards the memory of it made the dark thicker.

She stayed. Sent to bed from the altar, she kept another watch, at a table, among the very people she had been sure were lying, the ones without faith or hope: "For love of Thee she will sit at that table of bitterness where these poor sinners take their food, and she will not stir from it until Thou givest the sign." From there she wrote, "I have made more acts of Faith in this last year than during all the rest of my life."

At supper on the night before he died, the disciple whom Jesus loved leaned against his breast (). Afterwards, in Gethsemane, the Son asked for the cup to pass, and came back to find his friends asleep. "What, couldn’t you watch with me for one hour?" (). He went and prayed again, "My Father, if this cup can’t pass away from me unless I drink it, your desire be done" (), and came back, and found them sleeping again, "for their eyes were heavy." Jean-Pierre de Caussade, who wrote for souls lost in that kind of night, once asked, "Lord, can it not be said that Thy children sleep in Thy bosom during all the night of faith"?

By the next day he had other company. As they came out of the city the soldiers found a man of Cyrene named Simon and compelled him to carry the cross; he had not asked for it either. At the place of the skull they gave Jesus sour wine mixed with gall, and he tasted it and would not drink (). His friends had not been able to stay awake. He would not be put to sleep.

Then the soldiers cast lots for his clothes, and "they sat and watched him there" (). Passers-by wagged their heads at him, and the priests had a line ready: "He trusts in God. Let God deliver him now, if he wants him" (). His friends had fled.

From noon there was darkness over all the land, and no common light on the cross. For three hours the soldiers could not see what they had sat down to watch. At the ninth hour he cried with a loud voice, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" ().

George MacDonald heard the first two words. "He could not see, could not feel him near; and yet it is 'My God' that he cries." In the garden, MacDonald thought, the Father's will had still been in sight; on the cross it was gone. Had he been spared this one place, MacDonald writes, "there would have been one region through which we had to pass wherein we might call aloud upon our Captain-Brother, and there would be no voice or hearing: he had avoided the fatal spot!"

He did not avoid it. MacDonald asked one thing more: whether the Son, in that cry, was thinking of those who could not believe God was their Father, "knowing now, as he had never known till now, what a fearful thing it is to be without God and without hope." Then he stopped. "I dare not answer the question I put."

To anyone sitting in that dark he wrote, "Troubled soul, thou art not bound to feel, but thou art bound to arise. God loves thee whether thou feelest or not," and, a few lines on, "For he sees thee through all the gloom through which thou canst not see him." What he asks of us there would fit into a morning, "if it be but the sweeping of a room, or the preparing of a meal, or a visit to a friend."

Matthew records who had stayed when it was over, and it was not the three from the garden. "Many women were there watching from afar," among them Mary Magdalene, whom Julian wished she had stood beside, and "the mother of the sons of Zebedee" ().

On the road up to Jerusalem that mother had knelt to ask that her boys might sit at his right hand and his left. He told them they did not know what they were asking, and asked whether they could drink his cup. "We are able," they said (). In the garden they slept. She came to the cross. The places she had asked for were taken: there were "two robbers crucified with him, one on his right hand and one on the left" ().

When Joseph of Arimathaea had laid the body in his own new tomb, rolled a great stone against the door and gone, "Mary Magdalene was there, and the other Mary, sitting opposite the tomb" (). They could not see behind the stone.

Julian, who had seen, waited longer than that to understand. "I desired oftentimes to learn what was our Lord's meaning," she says. "And fifteen years after, and more, I was answered": "Love was His meaning." On the morning itself, while she watched and would not look up from the cross, she had been shown this: "Now He is uprisen and no more passible, yet He suffereth with us."

On the evening of the first day his friends sat in a locked room, afraid: the ones who had slept in the garden and fled when he was taken. He came and stood in the middle of them, and the first thing he said to them was "Peace be to you." Then he showed them his hands and his side (). Risen, he has not left the room.

Lord Jesus, we could not watch with you for one hour. You have watched with us through every one of ours.

You know the drive home afterwards, and the first morning we forgot for a moment and then remembered. You know the ones who could only watch from afar, and the ones who were there and cannot stop seeing it. And the ones who fell asleep in the chair and woke too late: your own friends slept through your worst night, and you loved them to the end. The part of us that wanted it over, you do not hold against us.

Be with whoever is in that chair tonight, or in a car outside a building they are not allowed into. Let them feel you near. If they cannot, sit with them anyway. And be with whoever is being watched, too far in to know who is in the room. Be a common light for them, on one thing.

Some nights we can pray only what you cried at the ninth hour, in the words of an old psalm: "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" Say it with us. You said "My God" when you could not see him; say it in us when we cannot. And when the time comes, and not before, teach us the last words you said, the ones that begin "Father, into your hands."

You showed a woman in Norwich that "the least thing shall not be forgotten." Remember the least things of those we have lost: a voice saying our name its own way, a coat still on its hook, the weight of a hand. We cannot keep them. Keep them.

Stay here, and watch with us.

your words

The silence is yours. A free account keeps whatever rises in it here, beside this reflection, and in your Notebook.

Begin here

Pass it on

Send this to someone walking with you. The card that travels with the link carries one of its lines.Or select any line above, and that one travels instead.

Draws on

Every voice named above comes from the Dia Logos Library — public domain, read in full. Nothing is attributed that cannot be opened.

Canonical4 voices (Medieval, Modern, Reformation)2 traditions (Catholic, General)5 Scripture passages

A periodic reflection — the chorus of the Church across time, speaking on one ancient theme. Written to the Church.

Elsewhere in the chorus

Dia Logos — the chorus of the Church, speaking across time, in dialogue with each other, with Scripture, and with you.

The voices you met here did not stop at one page. Read them whole; walk a passage through the week; keep your own words beside theirs.

Explore the Shelf