Skip to main content
Dia Logos

On the ancient themesthe darkness where God is

The God Beyond Knowing


Lord, we have stood at a distance a long time.

We know your mountain from the foot of it. The thunder and the lightning, the trumpet growing louder, the whole height of Sinai smoking like a furnace — and a people not three months out of Egypt, trembling at the edge of the camp. "When the people saw it, they trembled, and stayed at a distance" (). Then they said to Moses the thing we have been saying ever since: "Speak with us yourself, and we will listen; but don’t let God speak with us, lest we die" ().

We have found a hundred ways to say it. We buy the book about prayer and save the praying for later. We send the preacher up the mountain and wait for Sunday to hear what was said there. We read the saints — we are reading them now — because it is easier to hear about you than to be spoken to. A Moses is a mercy. A Moses is also a way of keeping you at the length of someone else’s arm.

And still the verse will not let us go: "The people stayed at a distance, and Moses came near to the thick darkness where God was" ().

Where God was. Not in the lightning, where the people could see. In the thick darkness, the one place on the mountain no eye could get into.

So we bring you the question we have been afraid to ask out loud. When we pray and nothing comes back — when the words go up and the ceiling is only a ceiling, when the old pictures of you have faded and we cannot make new ones — have you gone? Or have we come, without knowing it, to the edge of the cloud?

Others have gone in. They came back with a few words, and they told us the words would run out. Let them take us up as far as words can go.

Teresa of Avila stood at the foot of the mountain for eighteen years.

She tells it the way she tells everything, against herself. She could not pray without a book open in front of her. The book was "like a companion, and a shield whereon to receive the blows of many thoughts." Often merely opening it was enough. Only after Communion did she ever dare to begin without it.

For years, she confesses, she was "more occupied with the wish to see the end of the time I had appointed for myself to spend in prayer, and in watching the hour-glass, than with other thoughts that were good." Some days the doorway itself was the mountain: "the sadness I felt on entering the oratory was so great, that it required all the courage I had to force myself in." And some days, once she was through it, she found more peace than on the days she had wanted to pray.

The book was her Moses. Speak with us yourself. And she kept going in, which is its own kind of climbing.

The climb has a map, a few pages long, signed with the name of Dionysius, the Athenian who believed when Paul preached about an altar to an unknown god. Before it says a word about God it prays to be led up into "the super-luminous gloom of the silence." Then it takes Moses up Sinai.

He must be made clean first, and set apart. Then come the trumpets, many-voiced, and the lights pouring down in streams, and all of it is real, and none of it is God. Even at the summit, Dionysius says, Moses "does not meet with Almighty God Himself, but views not Him (for He is viewless) but the place where He is."

Dionysius is only reading Exodus slowly. Moses had asked to see the glory and was told that no one could see God’s face and live — and then, in the next breath, "Behold, there is a place by me, and you shall stand on the rock" (). Not the face. The place by him. And then: "I will put you in a cleft of the rock, and will cover you with my hand until I have passed by" (). The darkness in the cleft was his hand.

From the rock the way goes on into the dark, and it goes by cutting away. Dionysius reaches for a sculptor, who chips off whatever hides the statue in the stone and so brings to light "the genuine beauty concealed in it." Every name we give God — Good, Being, Life, Wisdom, Power — is true, and every one is too small, and unknowing is a chisel taken to the too-small. What falls away is marble dust. At the very end of the treatise he lifts the chisel against his own favorite word: "neither is It darkness, nor light."

None of this feels like sculpture from the inside. It feels like Moses’ week under the cloud — "the cloud covered it six days. The seventh day he called to Moses out of the middle of the cloud" (). It feels like the chair by the window where prayer used to come easily. The list of names we once prayed through every morning loses us by the third: a friend’s scan results give way, before we notice, to whether there is milk. The coffee on the sill grows a skin. We glance at the green numbers on the oven clock to see how much of the quarter-hour is left. Evelyn Underhill, who wrote for what she called normal people, told them to expect it: "long periods of darkness and boredom."

The old pictures of God fade — the picture on the Sunday-school wall, the kind face, the lamb across his shoulders, the warmth that once came so easily with the hymn — and will not come back. It may be the chisel.

Teresa’s own way up began on the floor. "My soul was now grown weary," she writes. One day in the oratory she came on a picture put by there for a feast, "a representation of Christ most grievously wounded," and the sight of it broke her: "I threw myself on the ground beside it, my tears flowing plenteously." She told him she would not get up until he helped her, and she says she was the better for it ever after.

She could not reason her way to God, so she pictured Christ within her, and kept him company in the hours when he was most alone — the Garden above all, where for years, nearly every night before she slept, she went with him. "It seemed to me that the being alone and afflicted, like a person in trouble, must needs permit me to come near unto Him."

On the feast of St. Peter, at prayer, the one she had kept company with in the dark came close without a picture at all: "I saw Christ close by me, or, to speak more correctly, felt Him; for I saw nothing with the eyes of the body, nothing with the eyes of the soul." She was frightened, and wept, until "He spoke to me but one word to reassure me." From then on, she says, he was "always on my right hand, a witness of all I did."

She went at once to her confessor, in great distress. He asked what form she saw. "I told him I saw no form." "How did you know that it was Christ?" "I did not know how I knew it; but I could not help knowing that He was close beside me." What she had, she says, was "a light not seen." Words go no higher.

And then God comes down. As he promised at the cleft, he stands there with Moses in the cloud, and passes by, and what comes first is not a sight but a voice, saying the name over him: "Yahweh! Yahweh, a merciful and gracious God, slow to anger, and abundant in loving kindness and truth" ().

Dionysius has a word for it: the Author of all things "is, as it were, cozened by goodness and affection and love, and is led down from the Eminence above all." Cozened: talked down the mountain by his own love.

From the sixth hour to the ninth, darkness covers the whole land. The thick darkness has come down off the mountain to a place called Golgotha, and God is in it again — this time as a man, crying out with a loud voice, "My God, my God, why have you forsaken me?" (). Someone runs with a sponge of vinegar on a reed. God has gone all the way into the dark, and it is our kind of dark: the edge of the bed at four in the morning, the floor cold under bare feet, the house ticking, a prayer said into a room that gives nothing back.

A soldier was standing opposite him, and when he saw how Jesus cried out and breathed his last, he said, "Truly this man was the Son of God!" ().

Thomas Aquinas, whose books about God fill shelves, ended where the soldier did, confessing what he could not see. On his deathbed, the story goes, he prayed to Christ hidden in the bread of the altar — "latens Deitas," hidden Godhead — and the prayer goes back to this hill: on the cross, it says, only the Godhead lay hidden; in the bread the manhood is hidden too. It ends by asking for the face: that seeing your face unveiled, I may be blessed with the sight of your glory.

The words ran out on the way up. The Word came down.

The people stayed at a distance. Moses came near.

Lord, we have come as near as we know how.

We have not seen you, and in this life we were never going to. Moses could not, and came down shining without knowing it. A soldier in the dark at Golgotha saw only a man die, and called him your Son.

So we will stop asking to see.

Let this dark be what Thomas called it at the end: a veil, and behind it the face we will one day see.

Take the names we have given you and cut away what is too small. Leave whatever is true. If the darkness is where you are, leave us the darkness too. If it is your hand over our eyes, keep it there until you have passed by.

When we pray and nothing comes back, teach us that the nothing is a cloud and not a wall. When all we can do is watch the clock, let us watch it in your presence. When the cloud has covered us six days, call to us on the seventh.

And on the ordinary nights, when the dark is not holy so much as dull, keep us going in anyway.

You came down the mountain. You hung in the darkness, and at the ninth hour cried out from inside it. You took bread and called it your body and put it into our hands. You have never once been as far away as we have stood.

We give you our distance. Take it.

Moses told the people not to be afraid. Say it to us. We have sent him up the mountain in our place long enough — him, and the preacher, and the book, and even these saints. Thank you for them. Now let them be quiet.

Speak with us yourself.

We will listen.

your words

The silence is yours. A free account keeps whatever rises in it here, beside this reflection, and in your Notebook.

Begin here

Pass it on

Send this to someone walking with you. The card that travels with the link carries one of its lines.Or select any line above, and that one travels instead.

Draws on

Every voice named above comes from the Dia Logos Library — public domain, read in full. Nothing is attributed that cannot be opened.

Canonical4 voices (Patristic, Medieval, Modern)3 traditions (Orthodox, Catholic, General)4 Scripture passages

A periodic reflection — the chorus of the Church across time, speaking on one ancient theme. Written to the Church.

Elsewhere in the chorus

Dia Logos — the chorus of the Church, speaking across time, in dialogue with each other, with Scripture, and with you.

The voices you met here did not stop at one page. Read them whole; walk a passage through the week; keep your own words beside theirs.

Explore the Shelf