Gratefulthe gift we had not asked for
thanksgiving as the spiritual discipline that transforms perception
Where we are
Near the end of his first letter to the church at Thessalonica, Paul gathers a run of short commands for a community learning to live together while it waits for the Lord. Three of them stand side by side here: rejoice, pray, give thanks, and do it always.
This week's word
“Rejoice always. Pray without ceasing. In everything give thanks, for this is the will of God in Christ Jesus toward you.”
Reflection
It is late in the evening at an Oxford college, and the porter has come to the room of a young man of the college named John Wesley, saying he wants to talk. L. Tyerman passes the story on in a footnote to his life of Wesley, from a source who says Wesley told it himself. After a little pleasant talk, Wesley tells the man to go home and get another coat; the story does not say why, though the answer suggests the one he had on was not much. The porter replies: "This is the only coat I have in the world, and I thank God for it." Wesley tells him to go and get his supper. "I have had nothing to-day but a drink of water, and I thank God for that." It is late, Wesley warns; the doors will be shut, he will be locked out for the night, and then what will he have to thank God for? "I will thank Him," replied the porter, "that I have the dry stones to lie upon."
Dry stones. Not a bed, not a fire, only the fact that the ground under him tonight will not be wet. Wesley pressed once more: with nothing to wear, nothing to eat and no bed, what else did the man thank God for? "I thank Him," returned the poor fellow, "that He has given me life and being; and a heart to love Him, and a desire to serve Him." The story goes that the conversation left a lasting mark on Wesley and convinced him "there was something in religion to which he was as yet a stranger."
Paul's words were written for a man like that porter, and for the young man of the college who could not yet understand him. "Rejoice always. Pray without ceasing. In everything give thanks." Paul can also tell a church to give thanks always for all things (), and the porter does thank God for his coat and for his drink of water. But the word here is "in," and it names where thanks begins: inside whatever the day has become. The porter did not thank God for his poverty; he thanked God inside it. And inside it he kept finding things to thank God for: a coat, a drink of water, dry stones, and beneath the stones, life and being, and a heart that loved. Thanks in everything is how we learn to give thanks for all things.
This is why thanksgiving changes what we see. Julian of Norwich calls it a kind of knowledge: "Thanking is a true inward knowing." Before it is ever a feeling, it is a way of knowing what is truly so. Sometimes, she says, it cannot be held in, "for plenteousness it breaketh out with voice," and we find ourselves saying, "Good Lord, I thank Thee! Blessed mayst Thou be!" But she knows the other days too: "And sometime when the heart is dry and feeleth not … then it is driven by reason and by grace to cry upon our Lord with voice," calling to mind his Passion and his goodness. On the dry days we say the thanks aloud before we feel it, telling over what Christ has done, and the words do their work: "the virtue of our Lord's word turneth into the soul and quickeneth the heart."
His Passion: Julian points us where Paul points us. The reason Paul gives is this: "this is the will of God in Christ Jesus toward you." Thanksgiving is what God's will looks like in people who live in Christ. A few lines earlier Paul has said what that means. God did not appoint us to wrath but to salvation through our Lord Jesus Christ, "who died for us, that, whether we wake or sleep, we should live together with him." That is the floor beneath every other floor. Whatever else is taken, this has been given, and the dry stones rest on it.
The Thessalonians did not hear these words from a place of comfort. They had received the word in much affliction, Paul reminds them, and with joy of the Holy Spirit (). He does not promise them that the affliction will lift. He gives them three commands that sound impossible: always, without ceasing, in everything. And then, as the letter draws to its close, he tells them who will keep them: "He who calls you is faithful, who will also do it." What he will do is what Paul has just prayed: that God would sanctify them completely and keep them blameless at the coming of the Lord (). The joy, the prayer and the thanks are commanded; the keeping of those who give them is promised. The one who asks them of us is the one who keeps us, on bright days and dry ones, until even the stones are a reason to praise him.
Sit with
Inside the hardest part of this week, what has been given to us?
Your own words belong here too — what you are sitting with, a prayer, a line to carry. A free account keeps them beside this devotional, and gathers each week's into your Notebook.
Begin herePrayer
Father, we thank you. We have not always meant it; some days we have said it through our teeth. Take those thanks too. Thank you for what we did not earn and could not have arranged: being alive this morning, the people who love us, the ones we have lost and love still. Thank you most for Jesus Christ, who died for us so that, waking or sleeping, we live with him. Open our eyes this week to what you have already put in our hands, and keep us from waiting to feel grateful before we say so. You have called us, and you are faithful. Amen.
Carry into the week
Give thanks in it, not only for it.
Pass it on
Send this to someone walking with you. The card that travels with the link carries one of its lines.Or select any line above, and that one travels instead.
Draws on
Every voice named above comes from the Dia Logos Library — public domain, read in full. Nothing is attributed that cannot be opened.
This week in the chorus
Elsewhere in the chorus
Dia Logos — the chorus of the Church, speaking across time, in dialogue with each other, with Scripture, and with you.
The voices you met here did not stop at one page. Read them whole; walk a passage through the week; keep your own words beside theirs.