Skip to main content
Dia Logos

Questioningthe gift we had not asked for

the lament that refuses silence when suffering feels unseen


Where we are

Psalm 102 is the cry of someone wasting away, mocked by enemies and sleepless with grief, who will later in the psalm lift their eyes to Zion and to the God whose years have no end. It begins with a cry to be heard and a plea that God not hide his face, and only then tells of a body failing and a heart that feels thrown away.

This week's word

“Someone in deep trouble begs God to listen, not to hide his face, and to answer quickly. Their days are vanishing like smoke; their bones burn; their heart has withered, and they forget to eat. Groaning has worn them down to skin and bone. They compare themselves to lonely birds of desolate places: a pelican in the wilderness, an owl among ruins, a sparrow alone on a roof, keeping watch. Enemies mock them all day and use their name as a curse. They eat ashes for bread and drink their own tears, and they say that God in his anger has picked them up and thrown them away. Their days stretch out like a lengthening shadow, and they are withering like grass.”

paraphrase

Reflection

The title of this psalm names no one. Others are signed, by David, by Asaph, by the sons of Korah. This one is headed "A Prayer of the afflicted, when he is overwhelmed and pours out his complaint before Yahweh." Rather than one person's story offered for our sympathy, it is a form left open for the next signature. Whoever is overwhelmed may pray it, in the words it uses, without first cleaning them up.

And the words are not clean. The one praying has stopped eating, "for I forget to eat my bread"; has wasted to skin and bone; has lost a good name to people who now "use my name as a curse." The only cause the psalm names is God himself: "Because of your indignation and your wrath, for you have taken me up, and thrown me away." What kindled that wrath, it never says. There is no confession of sin in its words and no defense of God, only the charge laid at God's own feet. The psalm does not soften it into a question, and still it calls the whole thing a prayer.

We find this hard to leave alone. D. L. Moody, in a book on the pleasure and profit of Bible study, came to the lonely birds of this psalm and found a lesson in each. The pelican "carries its food with it," the owl "keeps its eyes open at night," the sparrow "watches alone"; so the Christian should carry his food, the Bible, keep his eyes open, and watch alone. It is a good word about the Bible, and a long way from this psalm. The psalmist is giving no advice for the wilderness; he is telling God that he has become a wilderness creature and that no one is on the roof with him. "I watch, and have become like a sparrow that is alone on the housetop." His is the watching of a night without sleep.

Johann Arndt counted this among David's Penitential Psalms, though its words confess nothing, and he knew why the rest of us pass such prayers by. The carnal man, he says, has "no understanding of such sufferings, or of the complaints arising from them," and he points to Job's friends, who "reproved him as one that had lost patience." Arndt stands in a long line here, and he names it: Hezekiah, Job, David. He also admits that at the height of the conflict "the Scriptures themselves afford him no comfort." Even then Scripture keeps company. When the afflicted can find no comfort in Scripture, Scripture still holds this for them: a page where their complaint has already been written down and called a prayer.

Samuel Rutherford once had to write to a woman held prisoner at Dublin. He began with an admission: "I do confess myself unable to speak for the encouragement of a prisoner of Christ." Then he reached for this psalm. Her sighing, he told her, "is a written bill for the ears of your Head, the Lord Jesus," and "your meaning, half-spoken, half-unspoken, will seek no jailor's leave, but will go to heaven without leave of prelate or deputy, and be heartily welcome." He could not tell her when the prison door would open. He could tell her that the sigh would get out before she did.

The psalm itself goes on to say something like this. Further on it remembers a God who looked down from heaven "to hear the groans of the prisoner," and it pivots on two great words, "But you," to sing of a God who remains forever. The turn is there, and it does not settle everything. After its vision of Zion rebuilt, the same voice is back in its own trouble: "He weakened my strength along the course. He shortened my days." He goes on praying both at once: do not take me away in the middle of my days, and your years have no end (). Then comes the strangest company this psalm keeps. The letter to the Hebrews takes words from near its end, "Of old, you laid the foundation of the earth" and "But you are the same. Your years will have no end," and hears them spoken to the Son (). The one whose years have no end entered days that were cut short. That answers nothing the psalm asks. It only means that the God this complaint is poured out before has himself been taken in the middle of his days.

What, then, is this psalm saying to us now? Perhaps first that this may be said. The one who has stopped eating, who lies awake on the roof of their own life, who suspects that God has picked them up and thrown them away, may pray exactly that. They have only to pour it out, and to pour it out "before Yahweh": toward him, in front of him, at him if need be. That little word "before" makes the difference between despair and lament. Despair talks to the dark; this complaint has someone to address.

And perhaps it says to the rest of us that when someone else is on that roof, our part is not to explain the pelican. It is to let the prayer be prayed, unfinished, and to keep watch nearby.

Sit with

What would we say to God if we believed he could bear to hear all of it?

Your own words belong here too — what you are sitting with, a prayer, a line to carry. A free account keeps them beside this devotional, and gathers each week's into your Notebook.

Begin here

Prayer

Yahweh, hear. We have no better words than these, so we pray these. For those whose days are going up like smoke, who have forgotten to eat, who lie awake alone on the roof of the night: hear them. For those whose names have been made into curses: hear them. Some of us cannot yet say, But you. Some of us have said it and fallen back. Do not hide your face. Turn your ear. Answer soon; and if the answer does not come soon, do not let the silence be your last word to us. We are pouring this out before you because there is nowhere else to pour it. Amen.

Carry into the week

Pour it out before him, unfinished.

Pass it on

Send this to someone walking with you. The card that travels with the link carries one of its lines.Or select any line above, and that one travels instead.

Draws on

Every voice named above comes from the Dia Logos Library — public domain, read in full. Nothing is attributed that cannot be opened.

Written to the Church.

This week in the chorus

Elsewhere in the chorus

Dia Logos — the chorus of the Church, speaking across time, in dialogue with each other, with Scripture, and with you.

The voices you met here did not stop at one page. Read them whole; walk a passage through the week; keep your own words beside theirs.

Explore the Shelf